What I'm talking about is the eggnog you make at home, with real eggs, and a tastey bourbon, rum, or brandy. Anyone who knows me knows that my bourbon of choice is Maker's Mark. I've used recipes from the distillery, and one from Alton Brown. I prefer the Alton Brown version, with my Maker's Mark addition.
Here's a fantastic article that Alton Brown penned for Mental Floss about the history of eggnog, along with an updated, aged eggnog recipe.
Here's the older recipe by Alton Brown, that I love to use for my own eggnog:
Alton Brown's Eggnog
1 pint whole milk
1 C. heavy cream
3 oz. bourbon whisky
1 tsp. nutmeg, freshly grated
4 large shell eggs
1. Separate the eggs, carefully. Store. the yolks and whites in separate bowls. Place the
whites into the refrigerator.
2. Using a mixer, beat the yolks to a lighter color and texture.
3. While still beating, slowly add the 1/3 C. sugar.
4. While still beating, slowly add the both the milk and the cream.
5. Still beating, add the bourbon and nutmeg.
6. Wash your mixing beaters.
7. Beat the egg whites to soft peaks.
8. Still beating, slowly add the remaining 1 Tblsp. of sugar, and continue beating until you
get stiff peaks.
9. Turn down mixer to low, and slowly pour in your yolk mixture.
10. Once mixed, chill and serve topped with a sprinkle of fresh nutmeg.